"You did great, maybe be a bit more confident" is the most common interview feedback there is, and it is almost useless. It doesn't say which answer, what confident would sound like, or what to change. Getting better at interviews depends on feedback you can act on, and most people never get any because they don't ask for it in a way that produces it.
This post covers how to get specific feedback from friends, colleagues, recruiters, recordings and AI tools, and how to tell which of it to trust.
Why most feedback is vague
People giving feedback are trying to be kind and don't know what you want. Asked "how did I do?", they answer the easiest version of the question: an overall impression. Three things fix most of that:
- Ask about one answer, not the whole interview.
- Tell them what to listen for before you start.
- Ask for one change, not a general verdict.
Ask friends and colleagues the right way
Before a practice session, give the person a short brief:
"I'm going to answer 'tell me about a time you handled a difficult customer.' Can you listen for two things: whether it's clear what I personally did, and whether the result is specific? Then tell me the one thing you'd change."
Afterwards, ask follow-up questions that force a specific answer:
"Where did you start to lose interest?"
"What do you remember about the result?"
"If you were the interviewer, what would you ask next?"
The last one is especially useful. If the follow-up they would ask is "so what did you actually do?", your answer was too much about the team.
Choose people who will be honest. A colleague who has interviewed others is ideal. A close friend is often too kind; if that is who you have, ask them to find at least one thing to change, every time.
Ask the recruiter after a rejection
Many companies don't give feedback after a rejection, and some have a policy against it. Asking politely costs nothing, and a short email sometimes gets a real answer, especially from external recruiters, who want you to succeed for their next role.
"Thanks for letting me know. I enjoyed meeting the team. If there's anything from the interviews that would help me in future, even one point, I'd really appreciate it."
Keep it short, don't argue with the decision, and don't ask twice. If you get feedback, thank them. If you get a polite refusal, that is normal.
When feedback does come, look for the specific part. "We went with someone with more experience in X" tells you which gap to address or explain next time.
Record yourself and score it against a checklist
Your own recordings are the most available source of feedback, and the hardest to use, because most people watch themselves and only notice how they look. Use a written checklist instead, and score one answer at a time:
- Did I answer the question that was asked in the first two sentences?
- Is it clear what I did, as opposed to the team?
- Is there a specific result?
- How long was it? (Most answers should be under two minutes.)
- Did I end cleanly, or trail off?
Score each item yes or no, then pick the one with a no that matters most and re-record that answer. Re-recording straight away is where the improvement happens.
Use AI feedback as a second opinion
AI interview tools can give you feedback on every answer, at any hour, without the awkwardness of asking a friend again. That makes them good for volume: you can practise the same question five times in an evening.
Treat what they say the way you would treat a well-meaning colleague. In an AI mock interview, each answer is scored on relevance, depth and clarity, with comments on what to strengthen. If the feedback says your answer lacked a specific result, check the answer: was there a result? If yes, was it clear enough to hear? Either way, you have something to change.
Where AI feedback is weaker: it can't know whether your example is the right one for this company, and it only hears what you say. A colleague in your field can judge whether the story would impress someone in your industry.
Decide which feedback to act on
Not all feedback is right. A few rules for sorting it:
- If two sources say the same thing, act on it.
- If the feedback is about a specific answer and comes with an example, act on it.
- If it is about your personality or a general impression, ask for an example before changing anything.
- If it contradicts what the job ad asks for, trust the job ad.
Keep a short list of the changes you are working on, no more than three at a time. Trying to fix ten things in one week usually fixes none.
Close the loop
Feedback only helps if you test the change. After each round, write down what you changed and whether the next practice went better. A practice plan that builds this in week by week is in what a good interview practice loop looks like.
Your next step
Pick one answer you use often, write a two-line brief for a listener saying what to listen for, and ask one person to hear it this week.