Career & Negotiation
How to Ask for a Raise: Timing, Evidence and Scripts
Book a meeting for it and say what it is about. Bring two or three results from the last year, how your role has grown and what the market pays. Name one specific number, then stop talking. If the answer is not yes, agree on what would make it yes and when you will revisit it, in writing.
How do you ask for a raise?
Asking for more money feels awkward for most people, so they put it off, hint at it or raise it at the wrong moment. A raise is a business conversation: you are showing that your work is worth more than you are paid for it, and asking your manager to act on that. Managers have these conversations regularly. A clear, prepared request is easier for them to take forward than a vague one, because they usually have to make the case to someone else too.
Asking also matters more than people assume. A study using matched employer and employee data found that women and men asked for raises about equally often, yet the authors' results suggest that women who ask still do not get.[1] So preparation and a clear number help everyone, and they help most where the conversation is likely to be harder.
When to ask for a raise
Timing does not decide the answer, but it changes how easy it is to say yes.
| Timing | Examples |
|---|---|
| Good times | Shortly after a visible win; a month or two before budgets or reviews are set; when your role has grown since your pay was last set; when you have a fresh offer or market data showing you are underpaid. |
| Harder times | During layoffs or a hiring freeze; the week a project you led went badly; in a corridor or at the end of an unrelated meeting; by surprise in your formal review, after the numbers are already decided. |
Find out when your company sets pay. If budgets for next year are agreed in the autumn, asking in January means waiting a year. Ask your manager directly: “When are salary decisions for next year made?” Then start the conversation a month or two before that.
Ask for the meeting in advance and say what it is about, so your manager is not caught off guard: “Could we find 30 minutes next week? I’d like to talk about my pay.”
Is it risky to ask for a raise?
Less than it feels. Asking is a normal request, and the research that exists on it shows that people ask at similar rates and get different results, so preparation is where you can make a difference.
The study cited above found men and women asked for raises about equally often.[1] The gap was in what happened afterwards, so the useful lesson for anyone is to arrive with evidence and a number. The abstract gives no success rates, and this guide quotes none.
In the UK, Acas says an employee with no contractual or collective-agreement right to a rise can still raise the subject and give reasons, and that asking for a pay rise is unlikely to be a fair reason for dismissal.[6] That is UK guidance. Elsewhere the rules differ, so check your own labour authority if you are worried about retaliation.
The practical risk is a badly timed or badly prepared request, which can leave a poor impression without any formal consequence. The sections below cover timing, evidence and the words.
Build the case
The case has four parts. Write each down before the meeting, in a sentence or two.
| Part | What to bring |
|---|---|
| What you delivered | Two or three results from the last year, with a number or a concrete change for each: revenue, cost, time saved, customers kept, a launch that shipped. |
| How the role has grown | Responsibilities you have taken on since your pay was set: people you now manage or train, a bigger budget, a system you now own. |
| What the market pays | Ranges from job ads for similar roles (many places now require ads to show a range), salary surveys for your field and level, and what recruiters have told you. |
| What is coming next | One thing you plan to take on in the next year. It turns the ask from a reward for the past into an investment in what comes next. |
Leave out personal reasons such as rent, childcare or a partner losing their job. They are real, but pay is set on the value of the work and the market, and personal reasons invite the reply that everyone has costs. Keep the case about the job.
Keep the evidence short. Three strong points are more persuasive than ten, and they are easier for your manager to repeat to whoever approves the decision.
What goes on a one-page case sheet?
Five fields, one page, so your manager can forward it to whoever approves pay without rewriting it.
| Field | What to write |
|---|---|
| Current position | Title, level, current pay and the date it was last set. |
| Results since then | Two or three results, each with a number you can defend and who can confirm it. |
| Scope since then | What you now do that was not in the original role, with a date for each change. |
| Market evidence | Two or three advertised ranges for comparable roles, with the source and date of each. |
| The ask | One number, the date you want it to start, and the date you would like an answer by. |
Bring it to the meeting and send it afterwards, not before. Sent ahead, it can be read as a demand. Said first and shared afterwards, it supports your two minutes instead of replacing them.
Choose your number
Ask for one specific figure, not a range and not a percentage you hope they will round up.
Decide three numbers before the meeting: what you will ask for, what you would be happy with, and the lowest figure that would stop you looking elsewhere. Ask for the first one. A specific figure sounds researched; a vague range such as “somewhere around [low] to [high]” invites the bottom of the range.
Three places to find the evidence. Some places now require pay ranges in job ads: New York State, for example, requires employers with four or more staff to list a pay range for advertised jobs, promotions and transfers.[2] In the US, the Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes wage estimates for about 830 occupations, by state and by metro area.[3] Those Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics tables show mean wages, so use the median pay figure on the occupation's page in the Occupational Outlook Handbook as the second check.[4] Both cover a whole occupation, so ads for your level and city are usually closer to the figure you can ask for.
Base the number on your evidence. If similar roles advertise [ad low] to [ad high] and you are paid [current pay] while doing more than the role describes, asking for a figure in the upper half of the advertised range is easy to justify. No figures appear here on purpose; use the ones for your field and location.
You also have a right in some places to see your own position's pay scale. California lets an employee ask for the pay scale for their position.[5] Ask HR if you are unsure where you sit in the band.
If you are paid at the top of your band, the conversation may need to be about a promotion instead. The guide to asking for a promotion covers that case.
What to say in the meeting
Open with the purpose, give the case briefly, name the number and stop. The whole pitch takes about two minutes.
Illustration: a raise request, start to finish (names and figures are slots)
“Thanks for making the time. As I mentioned, I’d like to talk about my pay.
Over the last year I’ve taken over the supplier contracts from a colleague who moved teams, which is about [a third] more spend than I managed before. The renegotiation I led in March cut our packaging costs, and I’ve trained the two new coordinators.
I’ve looked at what similar roles pay. Most of the ads I found for this level are between [ad low] and [ad high], and I’m at [current pay].
So I’m asking for an increase to [your number].”
The example is an illustration: swap each bracket for your own fact. After the number, stop talking and let your manager respond, even if the silence feels long. The most common mistake at this point is to fill the silence by lowering the number or apologising for asking.
Listen to the first response carefully. Your manager may agree, ask questions, raise a constraint, or say they need to check with someone. Each of those needs a different reply, covered below.
Answering the common responses
Most first answers are not a final no. They are a constraint you can work with, and the reply that keeps the conversation moving is usually a question.
| What they say | A reply that keeps it moving |
|---|---|
| “There is no budget right now.” | “Understood. Can we agree on the number now and when it could start? If budgets are set in the spring, could we put it in for then, and could I have that in writing?” |
| “We only do raises at review time.” | “That makes sense. Then I would like to start the conversation now, so the case is in front of you before the review numbers are set. What would you need to see from me?” |
| “You are already at the top of the band for your level.” | “Then the question may be the level rather than the pay. What would I need to show to be considered for the next one, and can we set a date to review it?” |
| “What number did you have in mind?” | “Based on the market data and what I have taken on this year, I am asking for [your number]. (State one number, then stop talking.)” |
| “Let me think about it.” | “Of course. When would be a good time to pick it up again? I can send you a short summary of what I have shared today.” |
Avoid threats. “I’ll have to look elsewhere” may be true, but said in the meeting it turns a request into an ultimatum. If you do have a real offer, mention it as information: “I’ve had an offer at [offer figure]. I’d rather stay, which is why I wanted to talk to you first.” Harvard's Program on Negotiation advises against revealing a weak alternative, and notes that even a strong one, mentioned too early, can be taken as a threat.[7] The salary negotiation guide has more on counter-offers and anchoring.
If pay really is fixed for now, ask what else is possible: a title change, a review date in three months, a training budget, extra leave, or flexible working. Take the one that matters to you, and keep the pay conversation open.
After the meeting
Write down what was agreed the same day, while you both remember it the same way.
Illustration: a follow-up email
Subject: Following up on our pay conversation
Hi [manager name],
Thanks for the time today. To confirm where we got to: you’ll take the request for [your number] to the budget review on [date], and we’ll meet on [date two weeks later] to go through the outcome. You mentioned it would help to have the contract savings in writing, so I’ve attached a one-page summary.
Let me know if I’ve missed anything.
Thanks,
[your name]
Fill the brackets with your own facts. If the answer was yes, confirm the new figure and the date it starts. If it was no, confirm what you agreed would change the answer and when you will talk again, then put that date in your calendar.
Rehearse the raise conversation out loud
Most of the difficulty is saying the number and holding it when someone pushes back. That gets easier with practice.
Say your two-minute case out loud until you can do it without notes, then practise the replies in the table above with someone playing your manager. Ask them to push back with the constraint you expect most.
In the VirtualInterview.ai negotiation scenario you describe your manager, your current pay and your number, and the AI plays your manager defending the budget: asking why you deserve it, raising constraints and countering. The report scores Communication (20%), Trading (30%), Discipline (30%) and Composure (20%), and ends with a verdict such as “Strong position”, “Holding your ground” or “Needs more practice”. You can practise the raise conversation on the free plan. Scores are estimates from a practice run, and the role-play does not feed you answers during a real interview.
The salary negotiation practice page describes the role-play in full. For other conversations about pay, see the negotiation role-play scenarios.
Frequently asked questions
Short, direct answers to the questions people ask most often about this topic. Each answer stands on its own, so you can jump straight to the one you need.
How much of a raise should I ask for?
Base it on evidence rather than a rule of thumb: advertised ranges for similar roles in your area, the median pay for your occupation, and how much your role has grown. Ask for one specific number in the upper part of what the evidence supports, so there is room to agree on something you are happy with.
Should I ask for a raise by email or in person?
Ask for the meeting by email and have the conversation in person or on a video call, where you can hear how the request lands and answer questions. Then send a short written summary of what was agreed.
How often can I ask for a raise?
Once a year is a common rhythm, often linked to the review cycle. Ask sooner if your role has changed a lot, you have taken on significant new work, or you have clear evidence you are paid below the market.
Should I mention another job offer?
Only if it is real and you would accept it. An offer is strong evidence of your market value, but using it as a bluff can end with you being asked to take it. Present it as information rather than a threat.
What if they say no?
Ask what would need to be true for the answer to be yes, and by when. Agree on a date to come back to it, and ask whether anything else is possible now, such as a title change, training budget or extra leave. Then decide whether the answer changes how you see the job.
Will asking for a raise get me fired?
Asking is a normal request and rarely a reason for action against you. In the UK, Acas says asking for a pay rise is unlikely to be a fair reason for dismissal. Rules differ by country and state, so check your local labour authority if you are concerned.
Is asking for a raise different from asking for a promotion?
A raise is more pay for the role you have, usually justified by results, growth in scope or market rates. A promotion is a move to a higher level with new expectations, and is judged on whether you already work at that level. The evidence overlaps, but the argument is different.
Sources
The studies, statutes and primary pages this guide relies on. Numbers in square brackets in the text link here; where a claim has no number, it is our own guidance from running practice interviews.
- Do Women Ask? Artz, Goodall and Oswald, Industrial Relations 57(4), via the Warwick repository, 2018
- Pay transparency. New York State Department of Labor
- Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics. US Bureau of Labor Statistics
- Occupational Outlook Handbook. US Bureau of Labor Statistics
- California Equal Pay Act. California Department of Industrial Relations
- Asking for and awarding pay rises. Acas (UK), 2026-10-01
- Negotiation research you can use: should you brandish your BATNA? Harvard Law School Program on Negotiation
How answers are scored and which data we publish: data and research · methodology